When the sat upheld sebi s order, sahara moved to the supreme court in august 2012, which ordered sahara to refund investors money by depositing it with sebi. Read all latest updates on and about sahara vs sebi page 1. Sirecl and sahara housing investment corporation ltd. Sebi in return ordered saharas two companies to stop issuing the said. Now sebi, against company law and in violation of the order of the honble supreme court against. Under securities contracts regulations act of 1956, following powers have been given to sebi. Shicl apply to sebi for refund in terms of the order dated august 31, 2012 and the subsequent orders passed by the honble supreme court, particularly the order dated may 8. When the sat upheld sebis order, sahara moved to the supreme court in august 2012, which ordered sahara to refund investors money by depositing it with sebi. Sat rejects sahara plea against sebi order on mutual.
While the court reserved its order, sahara claims that it has already paid to 95%. Sebi, 2012 10 scc 603 press and media laws postponement orders coverage of court proceedings matters sub judice postponement of reporting of, by judicial order 1 purpose of. We have herein below in this article, discussed and analyzed some of the key. In nov 2011, sahara challenges the sat order obtains stay. How it all began it was an innocuouslooking complaint by one roshan lal four years and four months ago that sent watchdog sebi on trail of various illegalities committed by. Application for reconsideration of the sebi order dated february 27, 2015 9. Supreme court orders sahara to approach the securities appellate tribunal sat, in oct 2011, sat upholds the sebi order. The supreme court on 31st august, 2012 in its most anticipated judgment of recent times has directed the sahara group and its two group companies sahara india real estate corporation limited sirecl and sahara housing investment corporation limited shicl to refund around rs 17,400 crore to their investors within 3 months from the date of the order with an interest of. Exemption order under regulation 11 of sebi sast regulations, 2011 in respect of shree devarsh trust in the matter of vadilal industries limited apr 07, 2020. The supreme court on thursday directed sahara group chief subrata roy to appear before it on feb. Taking stern actions against sahara in the highprofile investor refund case involving over rs 24,000 crore, market regulator sebi on wednesday ordered freezing of bank accounts and. I have considered the prima facie findings and observations made by sebi in its order dated november 24, 2010, the show cause notice dated may 20, 2011, the replies filed by the parties and the submissions made by the learned counsel during the hearing. P it all started with sahara prime city, a real estate venture of the sahara group, filing a draft red herring prospectus drhp with sebi on september 30, 2009. Subsequently, sebi was in receipt of an application dated july 6, 2012, from sahara amc for renewal of certificate of registration as a portfolio manager.
The sahara judgment while upholding the securities exchange board of india sebi and securities appellate tribunal sat order 3 has also clarified ambiguities in certain provisions of law used by india inc. In the ensuing tussle, sahara made a successful attempt by getting a stay order on the sebi s order from the allahabad high court on th december, 2010. Sebi invites refund claims from pacl investors the new. Sebi orders sahara group to refund rs 14,000 crore to. I note that sebi vide its order dated june 23, 2011, had directed one sahara india real estate corporation limited. Finally, supreme court of india passed the judgment in favor of sebi. Shri prashant saran, whole time member, securities and exchange board of india sebi, had passed an order on july 28, 2015 directing the cancellation of the certificate of registration of sahara mutual fund with effect from expiry of 6 months from the date of the order. Sebi cancels saharas mutual fund licence business news. The group has been a major promoter of sports in india and was the title sponsor of the indian national cricket team, indian national. The sat also said that subsequent to sebi order against sahara mutual fund, the rbi had cancelled the certificate of registration granted to the sahara sponsor to carry on the activities of nbfc. While sahara prime city limited had filed its draft red herring prospectus drhp with sebi in connection with its proposed ipo, sebi received complaints that its group companies sahara. The securities and exchange board of india sebi has directed sahara mutual fund to surrender its certificate of registration by august 27 while winding up all but one of its schemes sahara.
Before the securities appellate tribunal mumbai order. In 2011, sebi ordered the group to refund this money to investors with 15% annual interest. Sahara refused to give information on the grand that sebi has no authority to call for such information. Sahara also refused to delve either any information or to cooperate with sebi. Such order vacating the stay was again challenged before the supreme court which on 12 may 2011 directed sebi to complete the inquiry and pass the final order to enable the. Final order in the matter of mindvision capital ltd. What is going on with the sebi and subrata roysahara. Even the securities appellate tribunal sat approved the sebi order on 18th october, 2011.
Sebi sahara dispute the long battle still continues. Sahara group files a petition in the supreme court challenging the allahabad high court order, which asked it to share full details of investors participating in its fundraising exercise with sebi. Ateendra mishra section a roll no48 1 introduction about the case on, 31st aug, 2012, supreme. Corporate fraud in india the sahara and saradha cases. Sebi orders attachment of properties of sahara chairman. Subsequently sahara filed an appeal before the supreme court of india against the sat order. The important issues that were raised in the two appeals before sat included whether the ofcds issued by the sahara group companies are public issues required to be compulsorily listed on a stock exchange and whether these are securities as defined in the securities contracts. But finally on 31st aug, 2012 honorable supreme court delivers the verdict against sahara and asks the above mentioned two companies to pay the collected amount i. Factual summary sahara aggrieved against the notice of sebi moved the allahabad high court and obtained stay. Sebi has referred to the maharashtra government a case of the sahara q shop issuing bonds as the activity did not fall under its regulatory purview, a letter issued by the securities watchdog said. Sebis jurisdiction a case report by sundar ramanathan the securities appellate tribunal sat, on 18th october, 2011, passed an order which could have wide ramifications for the entire corporate sector.
Two unlisted companies belonging to the sahara group of companies. It was against this order of sebi that sahara group had filed an appeal before sat. Sahara now attempted to evade answering the sebi and wade their jurisdiction. Since sahara was not cooperative with the authorities, eventually the stay order was vacated and a final order was passed by sebi on 23rd june, 2011. It has directed sahara group companies, its promoter and directors as jointly and severally responsible to return amounts. Sebi has accused sahara of deliberately delaying the repayment and pressuring investors to roll their bonds over into. Sebi invites refund claims from pacl investors markets regulator sebi today asked certain investors of pacl group to submit their claims for refund. Get latest news, breaking news about sahara vs sebi page 1. On detail appreciation of various contention raised in the notices, reply furnished by sahara companies, sebi found sahara contravening various provisions of companies act inter alia sections 56, 73, 117a, 117b and 117c as well as various clauses of dip guidelines as well as various icdr regulations. Order sahara mf securities and exchange board of india. The securities and exchange board of india sebi has recently released a. Sebi on the basis of complaint, issued a notice to sahara and called for information on ofcds. Sebi asked sahara to refund investors because it felt sahara was raising money in violation of capital raising norms and certain sections of the companies act.
Sebi files contempt plea against sahara on aamby valley sale. In the latest order, sebi directed cancellation of sahara mutual funds certificate of registration on expiry of a six month period from tuesday. Aggrieved sahara again moved towards supreme court. Pdf regulating equity crowdfunding in india a response to. In terms of the order dated august 31, 2012 and the subsequent orders. Earlier this week, sebi issued an order restraining two entities of the sahara group as well as certain promoters and directors from accessing the capital markets. Sahara challenged sebis november order at the lucknow bench of the allahabad high court, saying the capital market regulator did. Sebi says nearly 12,000 refund applications received sebi said it had received 11,956 applications involving 36,415 deposit acs and made refunds with respect to 8,734 applications involving 20,783 deposit acs. Sebi orders sahara mf to surrender licence by august the. Saharas proposal states that the bank guarantees can be invoked by sebi only if sahara fails to deposit the amount within a period of 30 days, or. Sebi is empowered to issue desist and cease order if after the inquiry board finds that the person has violated or may violate provisions of the sebi act or rules made there under. After sahara challenged the sebi order in the allahabad high court, the regulator moved the supreme court against an interim stay that the high court had granted. In order to ascertain suitable limits of regulation of the crowdfunding industry, three. While the court reserved its order, sahara claims that it has already paid to 93% of the.
Sahara has claimed that the said bonds are hybrid product, thus does not come under the jurisdiction. Sahara sebi case is the case of the issuance of optionally fully convertible debentures issued by the two companies of sahara india pariwar to which securities and exchange board of india had claimed its jurisdiction and objected on why sahara has not taken permission from it. Sahara india pariwar investor fraud case wikipedia. Sahara india pariwar is an indian conglomerate headquartered in lucknow, india. Sebi has considered the represcntation of sahara mf that implementation of the timelines specified in sebi order dated july 28, 2015, could lead to denial of benefits to the investors of sahara tax gain fund under the provisions of the equitv linked savings scheme, 2005 and may not be in the interest of investors. Sebi order in the matter of ms sahara india commercial. In sahara india real estate corporation limited and others. The summons for personal appearance of roy and three other directors of two sahara firms were issued by sebi to. Sebi went on to order sahara to issue a full refund to its investors, which was challenged by sahara before the securities appellate tribunal sat.
Sebi refers complaint against sahara q shop to maharashtra. The practical lawyer sahara india real estate corpn. In a major setback to subrata roy, sebi has found that another sahara group firm has raised over rs 14,000 crore in violation of legal norms and has issued a fresh order on wednesday to the company and its directors to refund the money to investors with 15 per cent annual interest. Securities and exchange board of india is made for protect the interests of investors in securities and to promote the development of, and to regulate the securities market and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto. Introduction earlier sahara india real estate corporation limited sirecl and. Sahara sebi case is the case of the issuance of optionally fully convertible debentures. Sebi orders seizure of sahara arms assets financial times. Bondholders of sahara india real estate corporation ltd. Following this, sahara filed a petition in the court asking for a stay order.
908 89 1453 1228 1457 1593 1318 1086 1142 1222 141 1110 1193 447 1166 1208 1353 570 1138 322 383 1408 293 1026 1085 1431 593 467 1269 694 498 182 899 1106 922 1083 1066